Aleenes Tacky Glue
This was my favorite glue back in elementary school. In 3rd grade, I enjoyed using it so much that I was frequently reprimanded for making a mess inside my desk with it. My friends and I would put it all over our fingers and roll it up into gummy little balls. So fun. It's also useful for gluing things together. My mom is much craftier than I am, and she uses it for a lot of projects. It's especially good at bonding things that Elmer's has trouble with like felt and other fabrics.