The Home Bakery
Using fine ingredients, the Home Bakery has honed great recipes for lots of classics, with fun twists (skittles sugar cookies?). They also offer tons of add-ins and will customize your order any way you like. A lot of the time they include many samples of various cookies along with your order, and will hand-deliver for free if you live locally :) Oh yeah, not to mention the 10% discount if you buy 4 baker's dozen!
