Original Sin: Hard Cider
Hard Cider is an acquired taste, for sure, but "Original Sin" has got a tangy sweetness that satisfies. Just sip it slow. Although sweet, it is truly "hard", packing a mean wallop if you don't respect its status as a liquor. Good cheer gifting (and getting.)
As long as I also get him something for only him I think it's perfectly acceptable to give my boyfriend a gift with massage oil... we can share it right?
Gold-plated silver locket with ruby, garnet, and tourmaline embellishments on the front and it opens up to a silver flower. One of those "goes with anything" pieces. It would make a really nice Valentine's Day gift too.