I recently purchased this set and so far I've very pleased with it. Here's the thinking that went into this purchase:
Plasma: pro - bright picture, cheaper than LCD, con - burn in, high power consumption.
The burn in risk ruins plasma for me. With video games, use as a computer, and crawls/o...morether features TV, I don't want to buy something that's going to degrade.
LCD: pro -bright wide picture, con - expensive
We were very close to getting a 52" Toshiba LCD, which would have been a fine choice. If you're going to sit 6-7 feet from your set and/or the extra $500+ you'll pay doesn't faze you, go with an LCD from Sony, Samsung or Toshiba.
DLP: pro - cheaper, larger sizes available, con - viewing angle, slightly thicker
For us, it really came down to price and the DLP features being sufficient. This set is available for well under $2000, and (if you can find it), there's a 56" version that should be under $1500. The usual arguments against DLP are
1. The lamp is $300 and needs to be replaced every few years. This is no longer an issue with LED based DLPs like this one.
2. Rainbow effect. I don't notice it, and it's supposed to be greatly reduced in this generation.
3. Viewing angle/brightness. Still an issue, but we're not throwing a bunch of super bowl parties, so it's not an issue for us.
4. Thickness. You can't mount this to a wall, but I don't care about that. This set is ~18 inches thick and about 70 lbs. It's bulky, but not heavy.
If you do pick a DLP, Samsung is the brand to go with. This model is also available in 56" and 67" models. If all the prices are doable, make your choice based on how far away you'll be sitting. For 8-9 feet, the 61" model is perfect, but it'll be overwhelming if you're 6-7 feet away.
After 2 months, I haven't had any problems with this set. With the money I saved by not buying a smaller LCD, I can afford to get a nice Blu-Ray player or a small computer to attach.
"The Samsung HL-T5089 ( http://tinyurl.com/yusznf ) is currently at the top of my must-have list, where televisions are concerned. For years, I've been looking to replace the old 30" CRT television the wife & I share at home: it's no longer able to reproduce deep black colors, the audio's a bit fuzzy, and I don't enjoy squinting to see details when I'm playing games from the couch a few feet away...."
"This is the TV I would buy if I was in the market for a new HDTV right now. It has all the features you'd be missing if you get any other TV:
* 25,000:1 contrast ratio. It means black color looks like black and not dark grey, and the picture will be as crisp as it gets.
* 1080p means you get the full HD.
* 120Hz means it doubles the number of frames per second (60Hz is regular). That shou..."
"Plasma rocks vs. LCD, 1080p rules, and flat screens forever! I also like that Samsung has a "True Black" technology that lets the viewer enjoy a truer, richer image than other plasma tv's."
"This 56-inch TV is the world's first with an ultra-wide 21:9 aspect ratio, letting you watch blockbusters filmed in the 2.39:1 format without letterboxing. The Cinema 21:9 LCD also features Ambilight Spectra light technology."