I went on a trip with a friend last year and was tempted to steal her Black Coffee pencil I adored it so much!! I didn't- but I did order my own the moment I got home! I got Black Coffee and Black Ebony - the black coffee is perfect for day - blue eyes - and its plenty dark! I actually use the black coffee more than the black ebony, bc the black ebony is sooo intense and I have light skin and eyes... but the consistency is great and they are very smudgy! Bring a qtip or 2 along with you tho, as it does bleed a bit throughout the day! I'm a convert from MAC Eye Kohl in Teddy and Smoulder - haven't used them since I got these tho! (via Sephora)